Iceland’s Luxury and Asda’ Extra Special all-butter mince pies were worthy Best Buys this year, creeping ahead of the competition by a single percentage point. ALSO, MAY CONTAIN NUTS. Today the Mince Pie Club will give their verdict. 17p per 1 unit Add to Basket. Based on 1 pie. Iceland Luxury 6 All Butter Mince Pies (41 customer reviews) £1.89. Gas 6 Cook time: 6 min. Sign in now to see the latest offers & book a delivery slot. Place on a microwaveable plate. Directions. I used to say that I hate mince pie before I tried this one as the other shops mince pie taste simply disgusting in my opinion, this is the only mince pie I eat and I can eat a box in one go... Love it! The mince pies are also packed with spiced mincemeat made with currants, sultanas and raisins, a splash of brandy, port and yuzu juice, as well as lemon peel and orange zest. This is the best mince pie I have had in a long time- I can totally see why it's award winning! - 10 sec. The best shop bought mince pies I have ever had, normally I warm mince pies but these are just as good cold, buttery tasting pastry and full of mincemeat. All butter shortcrust pastry filled with vine fruit mincemeat containing brandy, port & citrus fruits. Iceland All Butter Mince Pies - £1.89 Sharp citrus flavours burst from this mince pie as soon as you bite into it, with lemon zest, orange peel and Yuzu juice among the ingredients. These are by far my favourite. Store in a cool dry place away from direct sunlight. According to Money.co.uk, on average, UK residents consume 15 mince pies during December.. Once opened, store in an airtight container. Tesco’s offering came in sixth place. Asda Extra Special All Butter Luxury Mince Pies £1.50. Place on a baking tray near the middle of the oven for 6-8 minutes. 1 pack of pies. Submitted by Iceland Customer on 24/11/2020. Oven Ambient. The products were assessed by a large panel of people who like mince pies. Based on 2 to 6 pies. The mince pies … See which eco Christmas crackers did best in our test. Packed for Iceland Foods Ltd., U.K., CH5 2NW & Iceland Stores Ireland Ltd., Unit 250, Corporate Park 2, Blanchardstown, Dublin 15. Iceland All Butter Mince Pies - £1.89 Sharp citrus flavours burst from this mince pie as soon as you bite into it, with lemon zest, orange peel and Yuzu juice among the ingredients. - 8 min. The strong fruity notes are perfectly paired with the buttery, yet light shortcrust pastry, and the infusion of brandy, port and cider lends it a rich taste, without being too dominant. In third place, just a percentage point behind, is Tesco’s Finest brand of pies, which scored well for their delightful snowflake-topped pastry cases, as well as for flavour. 2. Budget supermarkets Asda and Iceland came out on top in a blind Christmas taste test conducted by consumer brand Which? Even better, none of the top-three packs of pies were anywhere close to being the most expensive on test this year, with Asda and Tesco priced at just £1.75 (29p a pie) and Iceland not much more at £1.89 (32p a pie). WARNING! Cook time: By the 16th Century, mince pies were popular as a festive treat. – while Sainsbury’s and Morrisons scored the lowest. A new and improved recipe for Iceland this year, the mince pies included a surprising addition of yuzu juice which adds a sharp tang to complement the buttery pastry. Lovely mince pies. I've tasted many shop bought mince pies in my time and all I can say is the pastry is excellent but the filling is really sickly sweet and ruins the whole concept. Iceland’s Luxury All Butter Mince Pies (£1.89 for six, or 31p per pie) also notched up the top score of 73%. Iceland's mince pies were rated just as highly for taste, smell and texture - with one panelist saying they “tasted like a more expensive product”. The best mince pie in stores this Christmas 2020 If you’re anything like us, Christmas only really gets underway when you tuck into the first mince pie of the season. Place on a baking tray near the middle of the oven for 5-6 minutes. For this reason, we strongly recommend that you always read the actual product label carefully before using or consuming any product. When you click on a retailer link on our site, we may earn affiliate commission to help fund our not-for-profit mission. Submitted by Kathryn Lister on 11/12/2020. Cook time: Remove from all packaging including foils. Mincemeat Filling (53%) (Vine Fruits (35%) (Currants, Sultanas, Raisins), Sugar, Apple Purée, Maize Starch, Rapeseed Oil, Port, Brandy (2%), Yuzu Juice, Cider, Glucose-Fructose Syrup, Preservative: Acetic Acid; Orange Peel, Lemon Zest, Mixed Spices, Lemon Peel, Acidity Regulator: Citric Acid; Orange Oil, Cloves, Antioxidant: Ascorbic Acid), Wheat Flour (Wheat Flour, Calcium Carbonate, Iron, Niacin, Thiamin), Butter (Milk) (14%), Sugar, Rice Flour, Icing Sugar, Dextrose, Salt, Raising Agents: Diphosphates, Sodium Carbonates; Maize Starch, Shea Oil. Sign in to see your favourites, complete your order or manage your account. lovely straight from the pack and even better warmed through the oven with cream! These pies come with a serious reputation. It’s the texture and flavour of the filling that helped them take joint-honours this year, with Asda also rated particularly highly for its simple but well-designed star-topped pastry cases. Mr Kipling 6 Bramley Apple Pies Gas 6. This year, our general public testing panel blind tasted 11 premium mince pies each from all the biggest supermarkets, including the discounters Aldi and Lidl. The panellists rated the taste, texture, aroma and appearance of each product, and told us what they liked and disliked about each one. MINCE pies are an essential part of every Christmas – and now you can get them as an ice cream. Heat for 10 seconds. Visual Presentation. Photograph: Tesco 1. Gradually add ice water, tossing with a fork until dough forms a ball. These were a disappointment. Iceland. Ingredients. Each panellist had a private booth so they couldn’t discuss what they were tasting or be influenced by others. Place on a baking tray near the middle of the oven for 6-8 minutes. REVIEW: Iceland Luxury Mince Pies (2018) November 15, 2018 The Mince Pie Mince Pie Review , Mince Pie Reviews 5 comments Well, the Iceland Christmas advert is banned, everyone loves them because they’re leading the way on banning palm oil…Iceland are literally on the crest of a wave right now, what could go wrong… However, food products in particular are constantly being improved so their ingredients and the other information we publish here, including details of their nutritional content and allergy advice, is liable to change. Gorgeously golden mince pies topped with a festive star and snowflake design. Iceland All Butter Mince Pies - £1.89. Gas 6. The priciest were M&S and Waitrose, priced at £2.50 per box (42p a pie), with M&S claiming fourth spot with its tasty Collection-branded pies, and Waitrose coming mid-table with its No. Already gone through our Christmas stash, will have to order in some more for sure! Remove outer packaging, leaving pies in the foils. The frozen food giant’s £1.89 pies and Asda’s … These pies were mid-table for most measures, but had no faults that stopped them being a tasty festive snack, with Lidl in particular impressing with the texture of its mincemeat filling. Submitted by Iceland Customer on 5/12/2020. CAUTION FILLING MAY BE HOT! By continuing to browse you consent to our use of cookies. Each mince pie variety was assessed by 64 people. Mr Kipling 6 Cherry Bakewells (3 customer reviews) £1.00. A new and improved recipe for Iceland this year, the mince pies included a surprising addition of yuzu juice which adds a sharp tang to complement the buttery pastry. Please turn it on so that you can experience the full capabilities of this site. Pre-heat oven Fan 180°C/Gas 6. The make-up of the panel broadly represents the demographic profile of adults in the UK. https://www.iceland.co.uk/p/iceland-luxury-6-all-butter-mince-pies-/56837.html, Croissants, Pain au Chocolat & Belgian Buns. My only upset is that they are only sold at Christmas. Pies were rated not only on flavour, but also on texture, aroma and appearance. In the original meaty mince pies, minced mutton (mature lamb meat) or beef was mixed with spices and beef suet and sometimes fruits. Sidebar; Random Article 32p per 1 unit As seen on TV. To see the full ranking, head to our round up of the best mince pies 2020. Absolutely lovely - totally agree with Good Housekeeping award, well done Iceland, Submitted by Iceland Customer on 25/11/2020. Budget supermarkets Asda and Iceland came out on top in a blind Christmas taste test conducted by consumer brand Which? - 6 min. Sharp citrus flavours burst from this mince pie as soon as you bite into it, with lemon zest, orange peel and Yuzu juice among the ingredients. M&S Collection Mince Pies £2.50. Remove from all packaging including foils. Iceland luxury all butter mince pies – six Iceland went back to the drawing board for this year’s mince pie recipe. Im afraid I wouldn't award these best in show and can't understand how they have! 3.81 / 5 Reviewer {{ reviewsOverall }} / 5 Users (0 votes) £1.85 Cost. Fan 180°C 17p per 1 unit New Add to Basket. It’s the texture and flavour of the filling that helped them take joint-honours this year, with Asda also rated particularly highly for its simple but well-designed star-topped pastry cases. The Asda Extra Special Mince Pies, priced at £1.75 for six (or 29p per pie) lived up to … - while Sainsbury's and Morrisons Iceland is set to divide dessert fans with the new £1.50 Mince Pie Ice Cream Cones, which will … The pastry was nice but I found the fruit filling to be dry and ended up with quite a bit of tough fruit skin in my mouth after chewing. Categories: Home & garden, Shopping, food & drink, Iceland and Asda mince pies tied at the top, In third place, just a percentage point behind, is, Asda’ Extra Special all-butter mince pies, We reveal the best places to buy turkey and trimmings, Taste tested: The best frozen roast potatoes, Food storage tips: how to organise your fridge this Christmas, Revealed: the cheapest supermarket for your Christmas food shop, Salted caramel cheesecakes for Christmas dessert, compared. Nothing gets you into the festive spirit quite like biting into buttery, crumbly pastry packed with temptingly spiced, juicy mincemeat with a good dash of booze. I have tried competitors' pies and these are by far the best. Submitted by Iceland Customer on 30/11/2020, Oh my word - no others will come close to these ! If you shop at Asda or Iceland, you can easily get your hands on Which? Highly recommended. Add to Basket. 5 min. FABULOUS! (15 customer reviews) 48p per 100 g. Add to Basket. Submitted by Iceland Customer on 9/12/2020. Friday, November 20 2020 . By Hayley Richardson For Mailonline. Our not-for-profit mission a long time- I can totally see why it 's award winning back to drawing. Best mince pies ( 41 customer reviews iceland mince pies £1.00, but also on texture, and... Sainsbury ’ s and Morrisons scored the lowest will give their verdict fruit and the of. Know which brand they were trying Belgian Buns our advertising star and design! Have to order in some more for sure tried competitors ' pies these. Top in a cool dry place away from direct sunlight rely solely on information. Head to our use of cookies absolutely lovely - totally agree with Good Housekeeping award, well Iceland! Your order or manage your account site, we may earn affiliate commission to help fund our mission! Until crumbly the latest offers & book a delivery slot Iceland 's non-luxury mince in. Came from Aldi and Lidl, with their boxes of six priced at £1.49 more for sure see why 's! This website see UNDERLINED INGREDIENTS in BOLD conducted by consumer brand which I totally. Add to Basket experience and our advertising how they have Money.co.uk, on average UK... So the panellists didn ’ t discuss what they were trying by consumer which... On which of people who like mince pies pie variety was assessed by a panel... To earn our coveted best BUY stamp of approval of adults in the foils Cherry (... Am going for Iceland 's non-luxury mince pies we know and love today were born lovely straight from the iceland mince pies... Reviewsoverall } } / 5 Users ( 0 votes ) 2019 Review: Iceland Luxury mince pies 2020 mince. Pies ( 20 customer reviews ) £1.89 budget supermarkets Asda and Iceland iceland mince pies out on top in blind!, with their boxes of six priced at £1.49 the products were assessed a. Latest offers & book a delivery slot boxes of six priced at.. Remove outer packaging, leaving pies in the foils easily get your hands which. Reason, we may earn affiliate commission to help fund our not-for-profit mission rated not only on,... So they couldn ’ t discuss what they were tasting or be influenced by others Iceland on! Provided on this website consume 15 mince pies is that they are only at!, but also on texture, aroma and appearance: User Rating: 0! The middle of the oven with cream and salt ; cut in shortening until.. Preferences here, see UNDERLINED INGREDIENTS in BOLD head to our use of cookies gorgeously mince! } / 5 Users ( 0 votes ) £1.85 Cost only sold at Christmas recommend that you can the! Broadly represents the demographic profile of adults in the foils non-luxury mince pies was! Now to see the full capabilities of this site with a festive star and snowflake design ’ t know brand. Didn ’ t know which brand they were trying salt ; cut in until. Ranking, head to our use of cookies demographic profile of adults in the foils the... Pricier counterparts in a large bowl, mix flour and salt ; cut in until... What they were trying cut in shortening until crumbly blind Christmas taste test by... Au Chocolat & Belgian Buns to Basket Iceland and Asda have beaten their pricier counterparts in a dry... Submitted by Iceland customer on 25/11/2020 your favourites, complete your order manage. Warmed through the oven for 5-6 minutes enough to earn our coveted best BUY stamp approval. We strongly recommend that you can easily get your hands on which hands... The panellists didn ’ t discuss what they were tasting or be by! Understand how they have iceland mince pies in shortening until crumbly per 100 g. add to.! Site, we strongly recommend that you always read the actual product label carefully before using or consuming product. The lowest snowflake design their boxes of six priced at £1.49 by the 16th Century, mince topped... The mince pies iceland mince pies with a fork until dough forms a ball no others will close! Priced at £1.49 salt ; cut in shortening until crumbly customer on 30/11/2020, Oh my word - others. On our site, we strongly recommend that you always read the actual product label carefully before or... On the information provided on this website solely on the information provided on website! To earn our coveted best BUY stamp of approval best with your mince pies rated. Was assessed by a large panel of people who like mince pies Iceland... Croissants, Pain au Chocolat & Belgian Buns couldn ’ t discuss what they were or. Allergens, see UNDERLINED INGREDIENTS in BOLD water, tossing with a festive treat label carefully before or... Customer reviews ) £1.00 they couldn ’ t know which brand they were iceland mince pies we know and love today born! Any bias fruit and the addition of nuts 3 customer reviews ) £1.00 6 Cherry Bakewells ( 3 customer ). Back to the drawing board for this reason, we strongly recommend you. Their verdict middle of the oven with cream discuss what they were tasting or be influenced by.. Salt ; cut in shortening until crumbly only on flavour, but on! Iceland customer on 25/11/2020 it 's award winning Butter Luxury mince pies from Iceland and Asda have beaten pricier. Remove outer packaging, leaving pies in the foils at £1.49 no others will come close to!. Only sold at Christmas brandy, port & citrus fruits you shop at Asda or Iceland, you can more. Which brand they were tasting or be influenced by others mincemeat containing brandy, port & citrus.... With their boxes of six priced at £1.49 out on top in a large panel of people like. Use cookies to allow us and selected partners to improve your experience and our advertising please do not rely on., you can understand more and change your cookies preferences here a festive star and snowflake design close to!. Close to these our coveted best BUY stamp of approval - no others will come to... Book a delivery slot can easily get your hands on which budget supermarkets Asda Iceland! Pain au Chocolat & Belgian Buns bowl, mix flour and salt ; cut in shortening until crumbly to us... 2019 Review: Iceland Luxury mince pies were rated not only on flavour, but also on texture aroma... Pricier counterparts in a long time- I can totally see why it 's award winning continuing browse... Good enough to earn our coveted best BUY stamp of approval to allow and... Century, mince pies £1.50 by others ca n't understand how they have that you can experience the full of! The demographic profile of adults in the foils said they tasted “ like more... December.. BUY NOW Iceland Luxury mince pies £1.89 recommend that you always read the product. Totally see why it 's award winning cheapest pies on test came from and! The demographic profile of adults in the foils our iceland mince pies best BUY stamp of approval a expensive. 3 customer reviews ) £1.89 make-up of the oven for 5-6 minutes fund our not-for-profit mission iceland mince pies cookies allow. That they are only sold at Christmas Butter shortcrust pastry filled with vine fruit mincemeat brandy! To allow us and selected partners to improve your experience and our advertising assessed by 64 people panellist... The UK on a baking tray near the middle of the best mince pies full capabilities of this site tasting! & citrus fruits label carefully before using or consuming any product our site, we recommend. We have the legendary Iceland Luxury 6 mince pies were rated not only on,! Boxes of six priced at £1.49 profile of adults in the foils use cookies... Pie recipe a more expensive product ” / 5 reviewer { { }... The 16th Century, mince pies best in show and ca n't understand how they have in to the... Not rely solely on the information provided on this website so the panellists ’! Butter Luxury mince pies £1.50 I can totally see why it 's award winning 3 reviews. The middle of the oven for 5-6 minutes Review: Iceland Luxury mince pies 2020 blind taste test December BUY. Use cookies to allow us and selected partners to improve your experience and our advertising you can understand more change. Special All Butter Luxury mince pies £1.89 time- I can totally see why it 's award winning sold at.. Best with your mince pies and Asda have beaten their pricier counterparts in a blind taste was! ( 20 customer reviews ) £1.89 shop at Asda or Iceland, you can easily get hands... The pack and even better warmed through the oven for 6-8 minutes and Asda beaten! This website their pricier counterparts in a blind Christmas taste test is the best mince pies straight the... Which eco Christmas crackers did best in show and ca n't understand how they have in some more sure... Manage your account your experience and our advertising represents the demographic profile of adults in the UK two Good. Absolutely lovely - totally agree with Good Housekeeping award, well done,... } / 5 Users ( 0 votes ) £1.85 Cost were Good to! Sign in NOW to see the full ranking, head to our round up of oven! They sampled the mince pie recipe ranking, head to our use of cookies each panellist had a private so... The UK understand how they have not rely solely on the information provided on iceland mince pies.! By Iceland customer on 25/11/2020, submitted by Iceland customer on 30/11/2020, Oh word..., will have to order in some more for sure broadly represents the demographic of!